If Real Wages Aren’t Rising, How Is Household Income Going Up? (Brookings Ignores The Federal Reserve Effects)

The prestigious Brookings Institute (home of former Fed Chairs, Ben Bernanke and Janet Yellen) has an interesting albeit misleading piece on the on why household income is rising while real wages are not.

The authors focus on 2015-2018 to highlight the Obama years (2015-2016) and the Trump years (2017-2018). Brookings makes it look like hours are up under Trump while wage growth has shrunk to the size of Melania Trump’s waist.

ES_THP_wagesvincome_fig1

An alternative view of what is happening is presented here:

rminchourlyreal

Yes, if you believe the real hourly earnings numbers, they have declined in terms of growth under the Trump Administration while real median household income has exploded!

Two tibits. 1) real hourly earning YoY are still higher in 2017-2018 than in 2009-2013. 2) Brookings ignore the pre-2014 era.

relmed.png

Real median household income ({RMINC) looks far better from 2014 to 2017 than it did from 2007 to 2012 (orange line). Yes, that declining RMINC line looks pretty bad if you are trying to convince voters that the economy is doing well. Particularly with average hourly earnings plummeting and remaining stagnant until 2015.

avghourly

So, in 2013, President Obama’s Administration and the US Census Bureau decided to change the way RMINC was measured.

redes.png

Starting in 2013 with a partial phase-in, which was fully implemented in 2014, Census changed the questions and the methods in calculating household income.

For example, Census, starting in 2014, began to “collect the value of assets that generate income if the respondent is unsure of the income generated.

Also, the government started to use “income ranges” as a follow-up for “don’t know” or “refused” answers on income-amount questions.

Okay, so guess the assets that you have that are generating income. The fact that the US has experienced massive growth in stock and housing prices thanks, in part, to The Fed’s highly accommodating monetary policies, particularly since wage growth has been so stagnant since 2009.

fedass.png

Not only did Brooking leave out the “wealth effect” generated by Federal Reserve monetary accomodation, they also left out that nominal average hourly earnings growth YoY is higher than anytime since 2009; it is only since The Fed began raising its target rate that real hourly earning growth has plunged.

fedhourly

Brookings deserves the Three Pinocchios rating for a grossly misleading analysis.

3pin

Hi-Diddle-Dee-Dee, a Brookings analyst life for me!

pinfox

“Fiat Franklin” D. Roosevelt Signed Gold Seizure Order In 1933, Purchasing Power Of US Dollar Destroyed (But Gold Prices Rise)

In 1933, President Franklin Delano Roosevelt (aka, “Fiat Franklin”) signed an exective order #6102 confiscating gold coin, bullion and certficates owned by private citizens. Why? So the Federal government could print and spend almost without constraint.

Executive_Order_6102_0

Between order #6102 and the Gold Reserve Act of 1934, gold held in Treasury and Federal Reserve Banks skyrocketed!

gold held in Treasury

How about currency? Here is an example of 1928 US currency before Fiat Franklin’s seizure order. Redeemable for gold.

lincolngold

Now here is an example of a post-1933 US currency (1934). Notice that “redeemable in gold” has been replaced by “will pay to the bearer on demand $10,000” … of paper. This is Fiat Franklin’s paper revolution!

1024px-10000_USD_note;_series_of_1934;_obverse

Look at the purchasing power of the US Dollar since 1933.

goldfedcondf

In 1971, President Richard Nixon enacted a plan that ended dollar convertibility to gold and implemented wage and price controls, which soon brought an end to the Bretton Woods System.

nixongold

Where was the US Supreme Court about Fiat Frankin’s seeming illegal executive order? The constitutionality of #6102 and the Gold Reserve Act of 1934 were ultimately upheld by the Supreme Court.

rooseveltsigninggoldcon

The second man from the left looks like George Soros.

And THIS is the worst call in NFL history! HOW is this not a fumble??????